My Profile | Active Users | Help | Search | Google Search


  
features@motivemag
Content Expediter



Offline

Member Since
8-13-2007
614 posts

Chicago IL

 Motive First Drive: 2009 BMW 335d« »

The upside to fuel crises, if there must be one, is that carmakers offer up all kinds of solutions that would have no appeal in a low-cost and stable fuel marketplace. How else do you explain Cadillacs with V-8-6-4 engines? The downside, of course, is that once the perceived threat is over (or once we get used to $3-a-gallon gas) the market corrects itself, and these oddball crisis cars disappear as fast as they came. In some cases (i.e., the aforementioned Cadillac) that's a good thing; in others, the march of legitimate alt-fuel progress gets kneecapped. Thankfully there's Europe, where gas prices are reliably obscene...

FULL STORY...

Lwize
Member



Offline

Member Since
12-4-2000
14230 posts

Los Angeles

 Re: Motive First Drive: 2009 BMW 335d (features@motivemag) »« »

I'd rather have a less powerful, more economical 325d.




HerrGolf
Member



Offline

Member Since
11-29-2002
4097 posts

Columbus OH
old bike

 Re: Motive First Drive: 2009 BMW 335d (features@motivemag) »« »

Awesome. Now bring over a 320d (not like I could afford to buy one, but if I could, it'd be a 2009 car I'd actually want).



I'm Audi 5000, y'all...
Seni0rl0c0
Member



Offline

Member Since
6-19-2000
2367 posts

Orange County CA
06 GTI - 05 1200GS

 Re: Motive First Drive: 2009 BMW 335d (features@motivemag) »« »

Quote, originally posted by features@motivemag »
once the perceived threat is over

global recession != end of oil crisis, just a temporary lull



Got Canned?

mikegilbert
Member



Offline

Member Since
11-29-2006
9671 posts

Seattle WA
8 Rings and an Oil Burner

 Re: Motive First Drive: 2009 BMW 335d (features@motivemag) »« »

Quote, originally posted by features@motivemag »
[img]The only transmission capable of handling that much torque is a GM-sourced six-speed automatic; the gear ratios are the same as the 335i's but the tranny features a taller final drive to take advantage of the massive torque spread.

I see no auto in this photo...cough...





flickr |Bestcoast | Funbags | crowBAR

BPCDubs » Giddy Up


Boxer2100
Member



Offline

Member Since
5-25-2004
3401 posts

Missoula MT / Columbus OH
2006 Impreza 2.5i

 Re: Motive First Drive: 2009 BMW 335d (Seni0rl0c0) »« »

Quote, originally posted by Seni0rl0c0 »

global recession != end of oil crisis, just a temporary lull

Yes, but the American Public has the attention span of a fruit fly.



Quote, originally posted by Turbiodiesel! »
It's like rubbernecking a horrible, high-speed accident made entirely of words.

Fritz27
Member



Offline

Member Since
3-8-2003
13220 posts

Lake Mary FL
Brazilmotors 1.NevarLoseT

 Re: Motive First Drive: 2009 BMW 335d (Boxer2100) »« »

Quote, originally posted by Boxer2100 »

Yes, but the American Public has the attention span of a fruit fly.

Yes, because SUV and truck sales are going through the roof right now.



PSN = PhilipGTI
Twitter
Quote, originally posted by Juniper Monkeys »

For the most part. If memory serves, it's also the cucumber capital of Japan. Hence the home-market ads for the FT-86 featuring Takeichi-kun, the cartoon cucumber whose meteoric rise through the underground drift world has shamed him in the eyes of his school-master.


Smoky_Llama
Member



Offline

Member Since
11-21-2005
3880 posts

Omaha Ne.
09' Golf Sportline TSI

 Re: Motive First Drive: 2009 BMW 335d (mikegilbert) »« »

Quote, originally posted by mikegilbert »

I see no auto in this photo...cough...

or a 5000rpm redline.



Bird Flu > MKIV Forum
Bristol Palin 4 Prez

Quote, originally posted by 1.8Tquattro »
Looks like he lost it right after chirping third.

mikegilbert
Member



Offline

Member Since
11-29-2006
9671 posts

Seattle WA
8 Rings and an Oil Burner

 Re: Motive First Drive: 2009 BMW 335d (Smoky_Llama) »« »

Quote, originally posted by Smoky_Llama »

or a 5000rpm redline.

I was waiting for a shot of the wide brake pedal



flickr |Bestcoast | Funbags | crowBAR

BPCDubs » Giddy Up


Numbersix
Member.

Offline

Member Since
11-7-2001
14448 posts

The Village
KAR 120C

 Re: Motive First Drive: 2009 BMW 335d (mikegilbert) »« »

Sounds great as performance diesels go--but I concur that I'd much rather have a 320d with a 6 speed manual.



JJB
Swedish Bucket
726
jonkarter
Member

Offline

Member Since
4-18-2007
1239 posts

wasilla Ak

  »« »

this has more torks than the 335i but is slower?
jwaters943
Member



Offline

Member Since
9-27-2001
8823 posts

Rhymes with Keno NV
2009 Soulless Transportation Appliance in Grey/Black

 Re: (jonkarter) »« »

Quote, originally posted by jonkarter »
this has more torks than the 335i but is slower?

In other news, HP still matters in terms of acceleration.

My guess is the diesel's HP/TQ figures aren't underrated like they are on the gasoline turbo-6.

Modified by jwaters943 at 5:06 AM 10-24-2008

Henrietta
Member

Offline

Member Since
1-12-2007
224 posts

Burlington VT

 Re: (jwaters943) »« »

Quote, originally posted by jwaters943 »

In other news, HP still matters in terms of acceleration.

My guess is the Diesel HP/TQ figures aren't underrated like BMW's gasoline turbo-6.


Modified by jwaters943 at 5:05 AM 10-24-2008


Mikedav
Member

Offline

Member Since
7-26-2002
5873 posts

Central London UK
06 BMW Z4M Coupe

 Re: (Henrietta) »« »

Drove an E92 335 about 18 months ago. Great car, sounds quite good for a diesel, refined, smooth and quick. But it feels nowhere near as quick as a 335i, and it's not as fun to drive either. I found when you drop the macho 'must have manual' attitude, the auto is excellent and perfect for the car - a manual box wouldn't suit its low revving characteristics IMO.

Great car, but no thanks...and thats at Euro petrol prices. Which have dropped 20% recently, which is nice.



06 BMW Z4M Coupe
Mongol Rally 2009 - The Movie
England to Mongolia in a 1.3 Hyundai - Rally Trip Report

ShavedFace
Member



Offline

Member Since
7-27-2006
1285 posts

Reading PA
2002 VW Golf GLS, 2007 Triumph Daytona 675

 Re: (jwaters943) »« »

Nobody wants the sedan, bring us a coupe.





-Alex
Cerebral Provocation
Member

Offline

Member Since
1-13-2005
1945 posts

Morristown NJ
1994 Camel - 2 humps - Bo Jacksons on all hooves

 Re: (Mikedav) »« »

Quote, originally posted by Mikedav »
Drove an E92 335 about 18 months ago. Great car, sounds quite good for a diesel, refined, smooth and quick. But it feels nowhere near as quick as a 335i, and it's not as fun to drive either.


Acceleration at fast highway speeds feels much faster IMO. It's just a different kind of fun.



FS: 1999.5 Jetta : http://newjersey.craigslist.org/car/374680196.html
Mikedav
Member

Offline

Member Since
7-26-2002
5873 posts

Central London UK
06 BMW Z4M Coupe

 Re: (Cerebral Provocation) »« »

Quote, originally posted by Cerebral Provocation »


Acceleration at fast highway speeds feels much faster IMO. It's just a different kind of fun.

I was much more impressed with it than I thought I would be, it just didn't have the BMW S6 magic IMO.



06 BMW Z4M Coupe
Mongol Rally 2009 - The Movie
England to Mongolia in a 1.3 Hyundai - Rally Trip Report

Oliver@triplezoom
tripleZoom Staff



Offline

Member Since
11-30-1999
38234 posts

Fredericton NB
1999 Cherokee Sport

 Re: Motive First Drive: 2009 BMW 335d (features@motivemag) »« »

As much as I applaud BMW for bringing over diesel cars, I'd be much more excited about a 120d or 320d.
MEIN_VW
Member



Offline

Member Since
7-29-2000
19931 posts

North of Toronto Ontario
2004 Jetta TDI Sport, 2003 Passat GLS 1.8T

 Re: (ShavedFace) »« »

Quote, originally posted by ShavedFace »
Nobody wants the sedan, bring us a coupe.

Forget the coupe. I want a 335d wagon.



Quote, originally posted by rosskoss »

I'd love to know how you determined the soul coefficient of a car through online photos.

Smindustries
Member

Offline

Member Since
8-31-2006
2697 posts

Northern Virginia

 Re: Motive First Drive: 2009 BMW 335d (mikegilbert) »« »

Quote, originally posted by mikegilbert »

I see no auto in this photo...cough...

That photo was placed in the article by someone who's clearly not detail-oriented. Note the tachometer redlines at 7,000, which the diesel engines will not achieve.

Chapel
Member



Offline

Member Since
6-23-1999
42532 posts

Salem MA
1995 S6 Sedan

 FV-QR »« »

they should have brought over the 320d too...
the 335d is pricing itself way too high



95 S6 | 92 GTi
Casey Jones - Team Post Killing Ninja
Chapel
Member



Offline

Member Since
6-23-1999
42532 posts

Salem MA
1995 S6 Sedan

 Re: FV-QR (Chapel) »« »

available Diesel engines:

318d: 2.0L 143hp
320d: 2.0L 177hp
325d: 3.0L 197hp
330d: 3.0L 231hp
334d: 3.0L 286hp

I would have been happy with a 177hp 2.0L Turbo Diesel



95 S6 | 92 GTi
Casey Jones - Team Post Killing Ninja
LordBass
Member



Offline

Member Since
3-17-2003
1980 posts

Dover NH
2002 Impreza 2.5TS .. 2009 Jamis Aurora Elite

  »« »

320d Touring six-speed with a moonroof and little else would be drool-worthy, and priced in this hemisphere.



Trance Lab - Electronic Radio
A weekly, two-hour podcast of fresh electronic music. Subscribe via iTunes

All the world's a [rally] stage

rudyr
Member

Offline

Member Since
11-29-2001
3800 posts

Santa Clara CA
'07 S2000

 Re: FV-QR (Chapel) »« »

Premium is down to 2.89 and falling while diesel is still close to $4 and holding pretty steady. Don't see the point of this car over the cheaper/faster 335i. It would be smarter for BMW just to offer a 3.0l tuned with a low RPM optimized cam that runs on 87 octane (~2.60 today). They had a model like this in the 80's I believe. One of the 325/525 models had this engine, maybe it was the 'e' ?

Edit - Yep, this one:

http://www.e30eta.com/ec.htm

Why not do the same thing again? 3.0l, high torque, low redline motor that runs on regular gas. I bet it would have ~200HP, on par with a 325D. Way more cost effective than the diesel both in upfront price and at the pump. Not to mention, no need for the complexity of a turbo charger; Just a basic, conservatively tuned inline-6 that would probably last forever.

Modified by rudyr at 10:11 AM 10-24-2008

Fritz27
Member



Offline

Member Since
3-8-2003
13220 posts

Lake Mary FL
Brazilmotors 1.NevarLoseT

 Re: (Mikedav) »« »

Quote, originally posted by Mikedav »
Drove an E92 335 about 18 months ago. Great car, sounds quite good for a diesel, refined, smooth and quick. But it feels nowhere near as quick as a 335i, and it's not as fun to drive either. I found when you drop the macho 'must have manual' attitude, the auto is excellent and perfect for the car - a manual box wouldn't suit its low revving characteristics IMO.

Great car, but no thanks...and thats at Euro petrol prices. Which have dropped 20% recently, which is nice.

Don't mind TCL, they'd take a rickshaw with a 6MT over a Veyron just to show their collective ass and how leet they are as drivers.

Also, the 335d is an interesting proposition, but I'm not the least bit interested. I think the 330d should be offered as well. The 320d is just stupid/not realistic/TCL-lalaland nonsense. Rowing your own in a diesel seems boring to me anyway, I'd rather have a bloody auto.



PSN = PhilipGTI
Twitter
Quote, originally posted by Juniper Monkeys »

For the most part. If memory serves, it's also the cucumber capital of Japan. Hence the home-market ads for the FT-86 featuring Takeichi-kun, the cartoon cucumber whose meteoric rise through the underground drift world has shamed him in the eyes of his school-master.


LordBass
Member



Offline

Member Since
3-17-2003
1980 posts

Dover NH
2002 Impreza 2.5TS .. 2009 Jamis Aurora Elite

  »« »

Quote, originally posted by Fritz27 »
The 320d is just stupid/not realistic/TCL-lalaland nonsense. Rowing your own in a diesel seems boring to me anyway.

The 320d is not nonsense - 177hp & whatever it has for torque is more than enough for daily needs. It can still be fun to drive, and it'd be more economical, cheaper, and lighter than any 335d.

It's ok if you don't like a manual diesel - some of us do like that. The point is moot since very few are likely to be offered in the US.



Trance Lab - Electronic Radio
A weekly, two-hour podcast of fresh electronic music. Subscribe via iTunes

All the world's a [rally] stage

someguy123
Member



Offline

Member Since
9-29-2005
10646 posts

Vancouver BC
2002 Passat V6 4Motion GLX

  »« »

These Diesels will be hot sellers in Spring/Summer.






Saintor
Member



Offline

Member Since
12-27-2003
4977 posts

MTL QC
Lowered white BMW E90 2007 on style 162 18"

 Re: FV-QR (Chapel) »« »

Quote, originally posted by Chapel »
they should have brought over the 320d too...
the 335d is pricing itself way too high

If they *have* to do the diesel thing not to lose any sales to competitors, they should have focused on a 330d, priced less than a 335i. It also does 0-60mph in 6.1s but manual.



Don't let kids play with formulas:
TORQUE answers the question "Will it be able to do it?"
POWER answers the question "How fast will it do it?
Robstr
Member



Offline

Member Since
6-8-2006
229 posts

Manhattan KS
1991 318is

 Re: (jonkarter) »« »

Quote, originally posted by jonkarter »
this has more torks than the 335i but is slower?

Oy, we've only had a million threads on this in the last week alone.

Turbiodiesel!
Member.



Offline

Member Since
2-21-2005
20681 posts

Denver CO
2003 Pontiac Vibe (chartreuse) looking for a nice Cherokee...

 Re: (Fritz27) »« »

Quote, originally posted by Fritz27 »

Don't mind TCL, they'd take a rickshaw with a 6MT over a Veyron just to show their collective ass and how leet they are as drivers.

Troof!



I Speak for the Trees at Speed:Sport:Life

Quote, originally posted by felixthecat, on why his genitalia are important to him »
Good god, I do have a wang and I just couldn't trade it in for a Prius.

HerrGolf
Member



Offline

Member Since
11-29-2002
4097 posts

Columbus OH
old bike

 Re: (Mikedav) »« »

Quote, originally posted by Mikedav »
Drove an E92 335 about 18 months ago. Great car, sounds quite good for a diesel, refined, smooth and quick. But it feels nowhere near as quick as a 335i, and it's not as fun to drive either. I found when you drop the macho 'must have manual' attitude, the auto is excellent and perfect for the car - a manual box wouldn't suit its low revving characteristics IMO.

Actually, low revving characteristics are a great match for manual transmissions. You have a much easier time short shifting and taking advantage of all the low end power and most importantly, when you put your leg into it, you can avoid an unwanted downshift.



I'm Audi 5000, y'all...
Saintor
Member



Offline

Member Since
12-27-2003
4977 posts

MTL QC
Lowered white BMW E90 2007 on style 162 18"

 Re: (Mikedav) »« »

Quote, originally posted by Mikedav »
Drove an E92 335 about 18 months ago. Great car, sounds quite good for a diesel, refined, smooth and quick. But it feels nowhere near as quick as a 335i, and it's not as fun to drive either. I found when you drop the macho 'must have manual' attitude, the auto is excellent and perfect for the car - a manual box wouldn't suit its low revving characteristics IMO.

Re-reading this, I am realizing that I am healed and no longer miss so much that 3rd pedal. The GM supplied 6-sp. autom. is a great companion to that marvelous I6. Of course, quicker ZF are as great or greater as well.



Don't let kids play with formulas:
TORQUE answers the question "Will it be able to do it?"
POWER answers the question "How fast will it do it?
gti_matt
Member



Offline

Member Since
10-9-1999
11292 posts

San Diego CA
1993 VW Eurovan GL "Herman", 2009 SLK300 6MT, 2000 Eurovan MV (SOLD), 1991 Golf GTI 8V (SOLD)

 Re: Motive First Drive: 2009 BMW 335d (Numbersix) »« »

Quote, originally posted by Numbersix »
Sounds great as performance diesels go--but I concur that I'd much rather have a 320d with a 6 speed manual.

Agreed. 0-60 in 5.9 is just rather unnecessary. Maybe offer it for those that must have the performance diesel, yeah, but I'd rather have a little less performance and even more MPGs as the more ideal balance for myself.



-Matt
7,001,084 Californians don't want me to have what they have.
gti_matt
Member



Offline

Member Since
10-9-1999
11292 posts

San Diego CA
1993 VW Eurovan GL "Herman", 2009 SLK300 6MT, 2000 Eurovan MV (SOLD), 1991 Golf GTI 8V (SOLD)

 Re: (jonkarter) »« »

Quote, originally posted by jonkarter »
this has more torks than the 335i but is slower?

I wonder if they just floored it and let the trans decide on the shifting, in which case revving it up might not be the best thing to do. It'd be interesting to floor it but have it in manumatic mode and force upshifts earlier (seems counterintuitive but with a low-end torque engine maybe keeping the revs down actually might help acceleration more?) to see if that actually would make a better 0-60 time.



-Matt
7,001,084 Californians don't want me to have what they have.
Acedia
Member

Offline

Member Since
2-3-2003
999 posts

DC
2008 VW GTI

 Re: (gti_matt) »« »

For those of you wanting the 320d, the 335d is the right choice for BMW in this market. Too many of their sales are dependent on brand perception, so it would be folly to offer a down-market car, especially a diesel one, as a small diesel will not feel remotely sporty to American drivers used to more power.

I, for one, want the 120d, but realize there's no way in hell we're getting it.



Physics makes us all its bitches

If you ain't gonna ride fly then you might as well hate

First  1 2 >  Last
» Return to The Car Lounge
Forum Jump
Quick Reply

ZeroForum 2.1.2. ©2008 RelyNet, Inc.

For advertising information Click Here