My Profile | Active Users | Help | Search | Google Search


  
features@motivemag
Content Expediter



Offline

Member Since
8-13-2007
614 posts

Chicago IL

 Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S« »

It took me the entire trip to Jerez, Spain, to come up with something negative to say about the current Cayman, but here it is: Even within the limited sports car market, Porsche's little two-seater has a limited appeal. Brand loyalists don't touch it because the engine — though still behind the seats — is too far forward. Sun gods don't bite because, hey, isn't it just a Boxster with a roof and a higher price tag? Techie types don't go for it because its CD player and outdated optional nav aren't much too get excited about; things like satellite radio, iPod jacks, or touch screens have never been part of the deal in Stuttgart. Casual cruisers probably aren't biting either, the automatic Tiptronic S transmission being a bit jerky, the engines not being class-leading in power, and the chassis not exactly supple. While the 911 fan club probably won't be swayed by the changes coming in 2009 (or ever), the revised Cayman should be able to find love among other shoppers. It certainly deserves it.

FULL STORY

IMAGE GALLERY

cougar
Member



Offline

Member Since
11-24-1999
14857 posts

Houston TX
2002 Ford Focus ZTS (his car) 2006 Mazda 3s Touring (her car)

  »« »

Just out of curiousity... can you Motive guys confirm that this is Mexico Blue in the middle? It looks pretty close, but perhaps a shade too dark... either way, gorgeous color.





Your car does not have soul, you just have a pitiful selection of adjectives in your vocabulary.
-... .- -. - .- -... ..- .-.. .-
I post useless garbage at http://twitter.com/salynch
stu@kilometer
VMG Staff

Offline

Member Since
5-15-2007
1819 posts

Chicago IL
1995 Volvo 850 T-5R Wagon, 2005 Mazda3

 Re: (cougar) »« »

Quote, originally posted by cougar »
Just out of curiousity... can you Motive guys confirm that this is Mexico Blue in the middle? It looks pretty close, but perhaps a shade too dark... either way, gorgeous color.

It was very early in the morning so my memory is foggy, but I'm pretty sure someone there asked that and the PR guy said "No, it's somethingsomething blue." I'll look into it.



KilometerMagazine.com -- VWvortex.com -- Mwerks.com -- Swedespeed.com -- Turbonines.com -- Fourtitude.com
stu@kilometer
VMG Staff

Offline

Member Since
5-15-2007
1819 posts

Chicago IL
1995 Volvo 850 T-5R Wagon, 2005 Mazda3

 Re: (stu@motivemag) »« »

Edit: It just came back to me--it is definitely NOT Mexico blue. It's Riviera Blue.






KilometerMagazine.com -- VWvortex.com -- Mwerks.com -- Swedespeed.com -- Turbonines.com -- Fourtitude.com
Son of a B...5er!
Member.



Offline

Member Since
8-10-2000
21264 posts

Finland, the EU
'03 SEAT Cordoba, '07 Santa Cruz Heckler

 Re: (stu@motivemag) »« »

Riviera blue?

Edit: That's it, took me a while between opening this thread and hitting Reply.



Quote, originally posted by xJeTTx »
hey, fake wimbledon, how about you leave the news to wimbledon?

wimbledon, can you make a thread about this, so i can read it?

726 toothpicks on the floor. Yeah, definitely...

cougar
Member



Offline

Member Since
11-24-1999
14857 posts

Houston TX
2002 Ford Focus ZTS (his car) 2006 Mazda 3s Touring (her car)

 Re: (stu@motivemag) »« »

Quote, originally posted by stu@motivemag »
Edit: It just came back to me--it is definitely NOT Mexico blue. It's Riviera Blue.

Ah, very cool... I'm a total trivia nerd and little details like this always fascinate me .



Your car does not have soul, you just have a pitiful selection of adjectives in your vocabulary.
-... .- -. - .- -... ..- .-.. .-
I post useless garbage at http://twitter.com/salynch
Professor Gascan
Member



Offline

Member Since
9-11-2002
7680 posts

Nowhere
'08 Cayman S, '09 STI

 Re: (stu@motivemag) »« »

Quote, originally posted by stu@motivemag »

It was very early in the morning so my memory is foggy, but I'm pretty sure someone there asked that and the PR guy said "No, it's somethingsomething blue." I'll look into it.

Time to test that memory a little more: are the blue and green going to be part of the regular colour pallet, or are they special order?



Quote, originally posted by Jrod511 »

One of these days I'm going to break my computer screen punching you Corbic.


justinsvr6
Member



Offline

Member Since
8-9-2001
2927 posts

Gaithersburg MD
1992 VW Corrado VR6--Prev. vehicles owned Black MK4 R32, 1987 GTi 16v & 1998 Jeep Cherokee Ltd.

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (features@motivemag) »« »

well i like the wheels....the rest is nice too but for the $$$$$ i'm certain the 370z will be 95% as good or better
stu@kilometer
VMG Staff

Offline

Member Since
5-15-2007
1819 posts

Chicago IL
1995 Volvo 850 T-5R Wagon, 2005 Mazda3

 Re: (Professor Gascan) »« »

Quote, originally posted by Professor Gascan »

Time to test that memory a little more: are the blue and green going to be part of the regular colour pallet, or are they special order?

The blue, the green, and the orange are all special order.

Everything in the back row of this photo is painted in normal colors, all the fronts are custom with the expensive body kit as well:






KilometerMagazine.com -- VWvortex.com -- Mwerks.com -- Swedespeed.com -- Turbonines.com -- Fourtitude.com
AP Zoutes
Member



Offline

Member Since
5-16-2006
113 posts

Tacoma wa
'84 Audi 4000S TQ(sold), 2003 350z enthusiast, 2000 tahoe

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (justinsvr6) »« »

Quote, originally posted by justinsvr6 »
well i like the wheels....the rest is nice too but for the $$$$$ i'm certain the 370z will be 95% as good or better

I made the same mistake.
Based on seat time in the last gen Cayman and owning a 350z their not even close.

6cylVWguy
Member.



Offline

Member Since
6-14-2000
15319 posts

Around Philly

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (AP Zoutes) »« »

If I could afford something like this, I would do it without thinking twice. I almost always love hardtop versions of cars that originally started as convertibles. I'd probably own a miata (a retractable hardtop doesn't count IMO) or s2k if they were available from the factory in a fixed top version. I guess that partially explains my current car as well.



Tom
Current: 94 SLC; 08 XF LTD-6 spd
Previous:06 GTI, 99.5 Jetta, 85 jetta coupe (x2), 93 Fox

cougar
Member



Offline

Member Since
11-24-1999
14857 posts

Houston TX
2002 Ford Focus ZTS (his car) 2006 Mazda 3s Touring (her car)

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (AP Zoutes) »« »

Quote, originally posted by AP Zoutes »

I made the same mistake.
Based on seat time in the last gen Cayman and owning a 350z their not even close.

I'd wager to say that the 370z is more of an upgrade to the 350z than the new/old Cayman... but, I could be wrong .



Your car does not have soul, you just have a pitiful selection of adjectives in your vocabulary.
-... .- -. - .- -... ..- .-.. .-
I post useless garbage at http://twitter.com/salynch
Voodoo.T
Member



Offline

Member Since
7-4-2002
9540 posts

Hopkins MN
'08 Saab 9-3, '88 BMW 325i topless

  »« »

I think the Cayman is highly underappreciated and a good looking car in person. Now if only Porsche would give it the proper balls it need and not worry about it wrecking 911 sales.



D
2008 SAAB 9-3 2.0T / 1988 BMW 325i topless

Fritz27
Member



Offline

Member Since
3-8-2003
13220 posts

Lake Mary FL
Brazilmotors 1.NevarLoseT

 FV-QR »« »

The Cayman doesn't do it for me, I'd take a Boxster over it any day of the week.



PSN = PhilipGTI
Twitter
Quote, originally posted by Juniper Monkeys »

For the most part. If memory serves, it's also the cucumber capital of Japan. Hence the home-market ads for the FT-86 featuring Takeichi-kun, the cartoon cucumber whose meteoric rise through the underground drift world has shamed him in the eyes of his school-master.


stu@kilometer
VMG Staff

Offline

Member Since
5-15-2007
1819 posts

Chicago IL
1995 Volvo 850 T-5R Wagon, 2005 Mazda3

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (cougar) »« »

Quote, originally posted by cougar »

I'd wager to say that the 370z is more of an upgrade to the 350z than the new/old Cayman... but, I could be wrong .

You're probably right. But like I said in the last line of the article, we'll be putting the Z and Cayman together this weekend and will report about that next week.



KilometerMagazine.com -- VWvortex.com -- Mwerks.com -- Swedespeed.com -- Turbonines.com -- Fourtitude.com
cougar
Member



Offline

Member Since
11-24-1999
14857 posts

Houston TX
2002 Ford Focus ZTS (his car) 2006 Mazda 3s Touring (her car)

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (stu@motivemag) »« »

Quote, originally posted by stu@motivemag »

You're probably right. But like I said in the last line of the article, we'll be putting the Z and Cayman together this weekend and will report about that next week.

Sweet, looking forward to it!




Your car does not have soul, you just have a pitiful selection of adjectives in your vocabulary.
-... .- -. - .- -... ..- .-.. .-
I post useless garbage at http://twitter.com/salynch
Mike@TripleZoom
Moderator



Online

Member Since
12-31-1999
12916 posts

NJ
2008 Mazdaspeed 3

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (stu@motivemag) »« »

Quote, originally posted by stu@motivemag »

You're probably right. But like I said in the last line of the article, we'll be putting the Z and Cayman together this weekend and will report about that next week.

Can't wait to see that review.

I love the Green and Riveria Blue on those press cars. Outlandish colors and Porsche's just seem to work so well together
Mike



"Ferraris are serious cars for serious people who drive around wearing a serious expression. The Gallardo can do serious, too. It has Audi electrics and Audi engineering. But as you careen towards the next bend on a wave of extraordinary sound, half blinded by your own upholstery, you’ll be making the noise of a howler monkey and wishing you were naked" The one and only Jeremy Clarkson
VTECjustkickedinyo
Member



Offline

Member Since
11-28-2008
1290 posts

Omaha NE
2008 Honda Accord

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (Mike@TripleZoom) »« »

It's time to play Awkward Cross-shop!

Would you get the new Cayman S or Mercedes C63 AMG?

stu@kilometer
VMG Staff

Offline

Member Since
5-15-2007
1819 posts

Chicago IL
1995 Volvo 850 T-5R Wagon, 2005 Mazda3

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (VTECjustkickedinyo) »« »

Quote, originally posted by VTECjustkickedinyo »
It's time to play Awkward Cross-shop!

Would you get the new Cayman S or Mercedes C63 AMG?

Man, that would be one painful decision. I think it all comes down to needs and whatnot, but if I, in my current childless, cares-a-bit-about-fuel-economy state went out to buy a $60k car today, it'd be the Cayman. But either would be a wonderful choice.



KilometerMagazine.com -- VWvortex.com -- Mwerks.com -- Swedespeed.com -- Turbonines.com -- Fourtitude.com
cougar
Member



Offline

Member Since
11-24-1999
14857 posts

Houston TX
2002 Ford Focus ZTS (his car) 2006 Mazda 3s Touring (her car)

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (VTECjustkickedinyo) »« »

Quote, originally posted by VTECjustkickedinyo »
It's time to play Awkward Cross-shop!

Would you get the new Cayman S or Mercedes C63 AMG?

Depends on if I was going to use it as a DD or if the wife and kiddo were going to be coming with me . If that weren't an issue, I can't see a single reason that I would buy the Mercedes over the Porsche.



Your car does not have soul, you just have a pitiful selection of adjectives in your vocabulary.
-... .- -. - .- -... ..- .-.. .-
I post useless garbage at http://twitter.com/salynch
Chris Stack
Member



Offline

Member Since
5-27-2008
2362 posts

Crystal Lake IL
03 NFR S2000 (me), 08 Jetta SE (wife)

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (features@motivemag) »« »

Quote, originally posted by features@motivemag »

It took me the entire trip to Jerez, Spain, to come up with something negative to say about the current Cayman, but here it is: Even within the limited sports car market, Porsche's little two-seater has a limited appeal. Brand loyalists don't touch it because the engine — though still behind the seats — is too far forward. Sun gods don't bite because, hey, isn't it just a Boxster with a roof and a higher price tag? Techie types don't go for it because its CD player and outdated optional nav aren't much too get excited about; things like satellite radio, iPod jacks, or touch screens have never been part of the deal in Stuttgart. Casual cruisers probably aren't biting either, the automatic Tiptronic S transmission being a bit jerky, the engines not being class-leading in power, and the chassis not exactly supple. While the 911 fan club probably won't be swayed by the changes coming in 2009 (or ever), the revised Cayman should be able to find love among other shoppers. It certainly deserves it.

That's really the problem. I'd LOVE to have a Cayman. BUT, I want a fun car as a convertible. So either A) I have THREE cars (DD, convertible, cayman) or B) I DD the Cayman and keep the S2000 in the garage. Problem is, then, that S2000+Cayman = Boxster S for less money. So a smarter move would be sell the S2000, buy a Boxster S, and buy some other DD. Maybe if I turn out to be sterile I can have S2000 and Cayman S, but since my wife and I plan on kids some day, I can't justify 2 2-seaters. Just doesn't make sense. So Boxster S it is. Or really, S2000 it is, since I can't afford a Porsche anyways



2003 NFR S2000
ElixXxeR
Member



Offline

Member Since
1-17-2005
5209 posts

San Francisco CA
G35c 6MT

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (cougar) »« »

Can't wait to read about the comparison with the Z.



"What you are, is by accident of birth. What I am, I created myself. There are, and have been, thousands of princes; there is only one Beethoven." -- Beethoven
stu@kilometer
VMG Staff

Offline

Member Since
5-15-2007
1819 posts

Chicago IL
1995 Volvo 850 T-5R Wagon, 2005 Mazda3

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (ElixXxeR) »« »

Quote, originally posted by ElixXxeR »
Can't wait to read about the comparison with the Z.

If anyone has any specific questions or thoughts about that comparo, now's your chance to post them up before we drive the two cars together this weekend.



KilometerMagazine.com -- VWvortex.com -- Mwerks.com -- Swedespeed.com -- Turbonines.com -- Fourtitude.com
EGSEDAN
Member

Offline

Member Since
8-12-2008
361 posts

Savage MN

 Re: FV-QR (Fritz27) »« »

Quote, originally posted by Fritz27 »
The Cayman doesn't do it for me, I'd take a Boxster over it any day of the week.

That's OK Fritz, I'm sure your "life partner" would agree.

J/k

CBJ
Member.

Offline

Member Since
9-16-2000
10851 posts

Windhoek NA
'94 Toyota LC80, '98 Subaru Legacy GT spec B

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (ElixXxeR) »« »

Did two different people write the first two paragraphs? First you say Stuttgart doesn't do something, for instance iPods and satellite radio, then you immediately contradict yourself say that both are options and that the former, iPod support, is fully integrated.
Ay_Caramba
Member

Offline

Member Since
1-22-2007
605 posts

Enyurdrims CA

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (stu@motivemag) »« »

Quote, originally posted by stu@motivemag »

You're probably right. But like I said in the last line of the article, we'll be putting the Z and Cayman together this weekend and will report about that next week.

That'll determine if the 370Z is capable of hanging with the Cayman (S), as Nissan specifically went after them. I think the regular colors available for the new Cayman is kinda mundane but the special-ordered colors are really striking.

stu@kilometer
VMG Staff

Offline

Member Since
5-15-2007
1819 posts

Chicago IL
1995 Volvo 850 T-5R Wagon, 2005 Mazda3

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (CBJ) »« »

Quote, originally posted by CBJ »
Did two different people write the first two paragraphs? First you say Stuttgart doesn't do something, for instance iPods and satellite radio, then you immediately contradict yourself say that both are options and that the former, iPod support, is fully integrated.

The first paragraph is about the current/outgoing Cayman. The rest of the article is about the new/upcoming one and how it fixes my one critique of the car it replaces. So what's being said there is that if you go into a showroom right now, you won't get iPod connectivity or a satellite radio. If you go in March, all that stuff will be there.



KilometerMagazine.com -- VWvortex.com -- Mwerks.com -- Swedespeed.com -- Turbonines.com -- Fourtitude.com
VTECjustkickedinyo
Member



Offline

Member Since
11-28-2008
1290 posts

Omaha NE
2008 Honda Accord

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (stu@motivemag) »« »

370Z vs Cayman S '09 predictions:

Numbers for the two are very close. But the Nissan doesn't come close to the Porsche's refinement, classiness, or driving impressions.

AP Zoutes
Member



Offline

Member Since
5-16-2006
113 posts

Tacoma wa
'84 Audi 4000S TQ(sold), 2003 350z enthusiast, 2000 tahoe

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (VTECjustkickedinyo) »« »

^^^^^^^^^^ x2
cougar
Member



Offline

Member Since
11-24-1999
14857 posts

Houston TX
2002 Ford Focus ZTS (his car) 2006 Mazda 3s Touring (her car)

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (VTECjustkickedinyo) »« »

Quote, originally posted by VTECjustkickedinyo »
370Z vs Cayman S '09 predictions:

Numbers for the two are very close. But the Nissan doesn't come close to the Porsche's refinement, classiness, or driving impressions.

I'd personally hope that actually, the Cayman ends up feeling like the more "raw" of the two, not the more refined.



Your car does not have soul, you just have a pitiful selection of adjectives in your vocabulary.
-... .- -. - .- -... ..- .-.. .-
I post useless garbage at http://twitter.com/salynch
Professor Gascan
Member



Offline

Member Since
9-11-2002
7680 posts

Nowhere
'08 Cayman S, '09 STI

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (cougar) »« »

Quote, originally posted by cougar »

I'd personally hope that actually, the Cayman ends up feeling like the more "raw" of the two, not the more refined.

I'm going to try and explain this the best I can within the context of what I think you're saying: the Cayman S is "raw" in that you feel everything that's going on with the car. You can tell through the steering wheel if you drive over a dime, you know exactly how much grip is left at all times, you can feel the clutch engage, etc. However, it's extremely precise and refined in that it isn't rough around the edges.



Quote, originally posted by Jrod511 »

One of these days I'm going to break my computer screen punching you Corbic.


Chris Stack
Member



Offline

Member Since
5-27-2008
2362 posts

Crystal Lake IL
03 NFR S2000 (me), 08 Jetta SE (wife)

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (Professor Gascan) »« »

Quote, originally posted by Professor Gascan »

I'm going to try and explain this the best I can within the context of what I think you're saying: the Cayman S is "raw" in that you feel everything that's going on with the car. You can tell through the steering wheel if you drive over a dime, you know exactly how much grip is left at all times, you can feel the clutch engage, etc. However, it's extremely precise and refined in that it isn't rough around the edges.

Yeah, it's a tough distinction, but think of it this way: The Cayman is "raw" in the sense that you feel everything the steering wheel is doing, but it's refined in the sense that it's so precise you can place it to the millimeter of where you want it. The 350Z is "refined" in the sense that you don't get as much feedback (or vibration/noise/whatever) through the steering wheel, but it's less "refined" in the sense that the controls are less precise.

The 350Z is a cavity-backed "forgiving" iron that is slightly clumsier for the pro, versus the Cayman which is more a blade; less forgiving but more precise in the right hands.



2003 NFR S2000
Rob
Member



Offline

Member Since
2-19-1999
10268 posts

Toronto, Canada

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (Chris Stack) »« »

I drove a 997S and own an S2000. The S2000 is raw, loud, mechanical, unforgiving. The 997 was different. It was way more refined. It was like driving a swiss watch. You could tell when the gears in the tranny notched in through the feel in the shifter, the steering was crazy, the engine sharp, powerful, mechanical, edgy but also the vibrations were curtailed. It was like an iron fist in a velvet glove - that touch of refinement to make everything very civilized, but without distilling any of the essence of the car. Kind of like adding a bit of water to scotch - it actually helps accentuate the flavors of the scotch.

The whole car was simply awesome. Very different to the S2000, but at the same time, I could see why the 911 is the benchmark in its class. After driving one, the R8 would have to be spectacular to beat it.




livingVoice
Member

Offline

Member Since
8-6-2006
2572 posts

S J ca
2007 G35 sedan

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (stu@motivemag) »« »

Quote, originally posted by stu@motivemag »

we'll be putting the Z and Cayman together this weekend and will report about that next week.

Cool. Can't wait. But I know what you'll say ... 370Z is close but can't match the Porsche engineering perfection ... or something like that .



"The vanity of others offends our taste only when it offends our vanity"
livingVoice
Member

Offline

Member Since
8-6-2006
2572 posts

S J ca
2007 G35 sedan

 Re: Motive First Steer: 2009 Porsche Cayman S (stu@motivemag) »« »

Quote, originally posted by stu@motivemag »

If anyone has any specific questions or thoughts about that comparo, now's your chance to post them up before we drive the two cars together this weekend.

Could you put them on the same track, same condition and record the lap time?



"The vanity of others offends our taste only when it offends our vanity"
First  1 2 >  Last
» Return to The Car Lounge
Forum Jump
Quick Reply

ZeroForum 2.1.2. ©2008 RelyNet, Inc.

For advertising information Click Here